When an Audit Isn’t Really an Audit

Many nonprofit organizations are required to undergo some form of financial examination each year.  Often times a church denomination makes the requirement, but it can also come from a national organization or parent organization for non-religious organizations.

These requirements are generally intended to promote accountability, protect resources, and provide assurance that contributions are being handled appropriately.  But there is something worth understanding: Just because an organization calls something an “audit” doesn’t necessarily mean it is an independent financial statement audit.

Not All Audits Are Created Equal

Let’s look at churches specifically.  In some denominations, a church may be required to submit its financial records to an individual or committee appointed by the denomination. That person or committee may review bank reconciliations, examine selected transactions, verify account balances, and determine whether financial procedures are being followed.

These examinations can serve a useful purpose. They may identify errors, highlight weaknesses in internal controls, and provide an additional layer of accountability.  However, they are not necessarily conducted in accordance with professional auditing standards.

An independent financial statement audit is a much more comprehensive engagement. It is performed by an independent CPA and follows established professional standards. The auditor obtains an understanding of the organization’s financial reporting and internal controls, assesses risks, performs audit procedures, and obtains sufficient appropriate evidence to express an opinion on the financial statements.

There is a difference between examining selected financial records and obtaining reasonable assurance that the financial statements are free from material misstatement.

 Why Does the Distinction Matter?

The terminology can create confusion for church leadership, congregations, donors, and even outside organizations requesting financial information. If a church reports that its financial statements have been audited, readers may reasonably assume that an independent CPA has performed an audit in accordance with professional standards. If the work was actually an internal financial examination conducted by a denominational committee, that assumption may be incorrect. This does not mean the examination was unnecessary or improperly performed. It simply means the nature and level of assurance are different.

There are several types of financial engagements that organizations should understand:

  • Independent audit: An independent CPA performs procedures under professional auditing standards and expresses an opinion on the financial statements.
  • Financial review: A CPA performs primarily analytical procedures and inquiries and provides limited assurance on the financial statements.
  • Agreed-upon procedures: A CPA performs specific procedures agreed upon with the organization and reports the findings without expressing an audit opinion or providing assurance.
  • Internal or denominational examination: An individual or committee examines financial records according to the organization’s own policies and guidelines. The scope and level of assurance depend on the procedures performed.

These engagements are not interchangeable, and the reports issued from them should not be represented as though they are.

 What Should Church Leadership Consider?

Church boards, finance committees, and pastors should understand exactly what their denomination or oversight organization requires.

A few questions are worth asking:

  1. Who is performing the examination? Is it an independent CPA, a denominational representative, or a church member?
  2. What standards are being followed? Is the work performed under professional auditing standards or internal organizational guidelines?
  3. What procedures are actually being performed? Are financial statements being examined, or are selected transactions and account balances being reviewed?
  4. What report is issued? Does it contain an independent auditor’s opinion, a review conclusion, or simply a report of findings?
  5. What happens when weaknesses are identified? Is there a process for reporting concerns and ensuring corrective action?

Churches should also consider whether the required examination is sufficient given the size, complexity, and financial activity of the organization.

 Compliance Is Not the Same as Accountability

Meeting a denominational requirement is important, but simply checking a box should not be the ultimate goal. Churches handle significant financial resources entrusted to them by members, donors, and the community. Those resources deserve appropriate oversight, regardless of the organization’s size or affiliation.

A financial examination may satisfy an organizational requirement, but it does not automatically mean that internal controls are adequate, financial reporting is reliable, or all potential problems have been identified.

Church leadership should view financial oversight as an ongoing responsibility, not simply an annual exercise.

 Know What You Are Getting

There is nothing inherently wrong with a denomination requiring its affiliated churches to undergo an internal financial examination. In fact, these requirements can be an important part of organizational accountability. The concern arises when the terminology creates an expectation that the work performed is more comprehensive or provides a greater level of assurance than it actually does.

An audit is a specific professional engagement with defined standards, responsibilities, and reporting requirements. The word should not be used interchangeably with every type of financial examination.

The goal should not simply be to say the church had an audit. The goal should be to know what was examined, who examined it, what was found, and whether the church’s financial resources are being properly protected.

That is what meaningful financial accountability looks like.

 

Contact Us

"*" indicates required fields

Interested in Learning More?

We are pleased to offer a complimentary consultation to discuss the needs of your organization.

Related Insights

Photo of When an Audit Isn’t Really an Audit. Photo of When an Audit Isn’t Really an Audit
Picture of an eye.

When an Audit Isn’t Really an Audit

Photo of Thinking About a Nonprofit Merger? Start With the Right Conversation. Photo of Thinking About a Nonprofit Merger? Start With the Right Conversation
Picture of an eye.

Thinking About a Nonprofit Merger? Start With the Right Conversation

Photo of Your Nonprofit Has a Conflict of Interest Policy. Now What?. Photo of Your Nonprofit Has a Conflict of Interest Policy. Now What?
Picture of an eye.

Your Nonprofit Has a Conflict of Interest Policy. Now What?

Disclaimer: The information contained in Dulin, Ward & DeWald’s blog is provided for general educational purposes only and should not be construed as financial or legal advice on any subject matter. Before taking any action based on this information, we strongly encourage you to consult competent legal, accounting or other professional advice about your specific situation. Questions on blog posts may be submitted to your DWD representative.